Skip to main content

Mr. and Mrs. Smith

Mrs. Smith or Mrs. Jones-Smith. Which is more likely to be the feminist? Tannen points out that "all married women's surnames are marked," and these labels become a factor for judgment, while a male will never be judged for being a Mr. This struck me as the only indisputable form of being "marked" as a woman, yet I soon came to realize that even this may be flawed.

In many Asian cultures, particularly Chinese, women tend to keep their surnames as they get married. And to be perfectly candid, I didn't attribute this to an act of female empowerment, as I would have in Western culture. (Unfortunately, this is where my racial fixedness comes in, but that discussion is for another time.) I assumed this tendency was a tradition and simply a norm in society, making me doubt the validity of using surnames to measure being "marked."

From what I've found, like most cultures, the Chinese have a deeply patriarchal society where the family one is born into is heavily emphasized. In this sense, females keep their maiden names because they "belong to their father" ("Why I'm Keeping My Vietnamese Surname When I Marry"). Not only that, but the New York Times indicates that this difference in the last name also keeps her "an outsider in her husband's family." In fact, the Chinese would think, "doesn't letting a woman take your surname raise her status?"

Although this practice-- or lack of practice, in this case-- doesn't necessarily call for explicit judgments of character, the surname retention may subconsciously lead to sentiments of inferiority as a female. All names indicate something about a person--presumably, their race--but females are further marked for their status.

Comments

  1. LanceFebruary 2, 2020 at 8:22 AM

    Though names usually have 3 Chinese characters, but they also at times have 4, 1st one being their husband's. As like in other oriental cultures, only males, can formally carry on the family name. I think the retention of her own's, is to mark her side of the family's name, in her own personal way out of recognition and respect, more than any other grounds, it's like Hillary Rodham Clinton.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Abby RizkFebruary 2, 2020 at 9:08 AM

    I love how you did research and applied the text to your own culture. I do find it interesting that only some parts of the world change their surnames, and I agree that Tannen's argument is flawed in this way.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Julia StarrFebruary 2, 2020 at 11:11 AM

    I liked how you incorporated research in your post, I wasn't really aware that other cultures didn't even change their surnames which I found interesting.

    ReplyDelete
  4. ben prydeFebruary 2, 2020 at 11:44 AM

    I think you did a really good job on teaching the reader about Chinese characters and what they mean. Good job

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A Gray Area

As we discuss the roles of pictures and words in conveying a story, I become mildly conflicted in several aspects. First, and most obviously, which one does the better job? To me, both forms of storytelling allow for creativity and personal thought. But, while writing is both specific and yet very imagination-based, illustrations tend to be only the latter. A drawing calls for "broader topics" (McCloud 815) of assumptions. And while that may be seen as a good thing, I see it as a source of miscommunication. Because images are open to so many different interpretations, often, the author's intended meaning is not truly understood. Similarly, I regularly find myself wondering if, as readers, we also look too much into the text and find meaning when the author actually had none. What if the author didn't really have a specific theme in mind and just wanted to write an amusing story? Of course, I may just be too simple-minded and unqualified, but I find myself doubting t...
7 comments
Read more

Never Let Anyone Dull your Sparkle! (unless you're the 1920s)

Knowing that the Great Gatsby is set in the 1920s, I had been looking forward to reading the book for so long. This decade has always fascinated me because of its creation of a new society, which--for the first time in history--is relatable to ours. In my perspective, before the 1920s, history was bleak, the human lifestyle seemed near archaic, and nothing was the slightest bit comparable to the twenty-first century. But at the turn of a new decade, Roaring Twenties brought along the "New Woman" and the birth of mass culture, including a surge of trends and technology. A curtain for my car window? Of course, I'll buy it! However, in the Great Gatsby , I seemed to have forgotten that the book I was reading was about my favorite decade! Where's the excitement and innovation? Why aren't advertisements for the Model-T being shoved in my face? Needless to say, I was underwhelmed! But I don't think I was alone in thinking this. In fact, Fitzgerald's mess...
7 comments
Read more

War and Peace

Violence. The Merriam-Webster dictionary defines it as the use of physical force so as to injure, abuse, damage, or destroy. In most ways violence can seem very obvious because of its portrayal in movies, video games, and crime; you picture blood, weapons, and fighting. But there seem to be sources of violence that tend to be less physical.  While looking at an image of a young boy in the arms of, presumably, his father whose head was covered by a bag, it seems that most of us agreed that it isn't  a violent image. In disbelief, Mrs. Valentino exclaimed that it is actually violent. However, in my head, it came across as almost peaceful. Now, I do acknowledge the sadness of this image, but what I really saw was a boy reuniting with his father among the vastness of a desert. There was a stillness that was reflected by the picture instead of the usual chaos that physical violence entails. So what really is violence? We can almost all agree that there should be a line dra...
7 comments
Read more